How Free Lives Turned a Doubtful Prototype Into Dressmaker, a Surprise Steam Hit

Free Lives nearly passed on Dressmaker because its early numbers looked uncertain. The studio's developer explains the signals that pushed the cozy game into a surprise hit with thousands of positive Steam reviews.

Dressmaker, the cozy game from Cozy Lives and Free Lives, has become one of the year's surprise indie hits, with thousands of "overwhelmingly positive" reviews on Steam. Before that happened, its makers were not sure the game would find an audience at all, according to programmer and designer Ruan Rothman, who spoke to Game Developer.

Free Lives judges pitches with a playable prototype, usually posted on itch.io. The studio looks at three signals: whether the prototype gets engagement and downloads there, whether social media responds to a mini-trailer or gameplay clips, and whether content creators make videos without being asked. The first Dressmaker prototype reached about 10,000 downloads in its first month on itch.io, which the team considered weak next to its earlier Stick it to the Stickman, which passed 100,000 downloads. That game later underperformed on Steam, and Dressmaker drew no organic creator interest and no publisher offers.

The team ran a second social media push and contacted a few influencers. The response on Instagram and TikTok suggested a real audience for a dressmaking game, so the studio moved ahead with a limited scope. Rothman says the lesson is not settled. Any single metric can mislead, and some prototypes that gained traction online failed to convert into downloads or Steam sales. The team now looks for several signals that agree before committing to a project.